Articles
Glossary of Terms
Calculation Tools
Unit Converters
Popular Topics
Get a Quote
Assembly Services
Materials
Rare Earth Magnets
About Neodymium Iron Boron
Neodymium Magnets
About Samarium Cobalt
Samarium Cobalt Magnets
Neodymium vs. Samarium
Permanent Magnets
Neodymium Iron Boron vs. Samarium Cobalt, a comparison
Back to Articles Article Rating:

Often times, questions arise whether it is better to use Neodymium Iron Boron or Samarium Cobalt in an application.

Here are some comparisons; they are limited to the sintered series, no consideration is given to the bonded series. The boxes with the light blue background indicate application/requirement. The boxes with the light yellow background indicate excellence in this application/requirement area.

Neodymium Iron Boron (NdFeB)

Samarium Cobalt (SmCo)

High Temperature Applications

Higher Hci materials can be used as high as 200°C, moderate Hci materials should be used around 150°C. Low Hci materials should be used under 100°C

SmCo can be used at substantially higher temperatures than NdFeB. The material can take continuous temperatures above 250°C

Loss of flux density at elevated temperatures (see temperature effects on magnets for more information)

Loses 0.11% of Br/°C. See Temperature effects on Br and Hci of NdFeB

Loses about 0.03% of Br/°C

Humid environments

Surface treatment should be used. Options are nickel, IVD or polymer coatings such as PR1010, PR1020, or PM1000. Oxidation can be a problem

Surface treatment is not required. Does not oxidize

Hydrogen rich atmosphere

Not recommended, hydrogenation occurs, causing the magnet material to disintegrate

No known adverse effects

Cost of part

Lower cost generally

Typically higher cost than NdFeB

Radiation environment

Can be damaged by radiation, mainly gamma rays

S2471 and higher grades are very stable in radiation environments

Mechanical Strength

Mechanically very strong, not as brittle as SmCo

Brittle

Clean Room environments

Surface treatment is recommended

Surface treatment is not required

Vacuum Applications

Does not need to be coated, however, if desired, Nickel or IVD is recommended. Polymer coatings such as PR1010 can be used, but not recommended in ultra high vacuum or high temperature applications in vacuum due to outgassing. Nickel and IVD are metallic and therefore do not outgas

Surface treatment is not required. However, the material is fairly porous; parts may outgas for a limited duration before high vacuums can be achieved

High field requirements

Can achieve much higher fields, higher energy products achievable (55 MGOe available).

Highest energy product materials are S3264 and S3069, generally very difficult to obtain higher than 30 MGOe.

Cryogenic temperatures

Only special formulation grades can be used (call for more information on this)

Works well in cryogenic temperatures.

Aerospace applications

Gaining popularity in aerospace applications. Being used with and without surface treatments. Used on aircrafts, missiles, and satellite programs very successfully. Also qualified and used on the Space Station

Very popular in aerospace and defense applications. Has substantial history in military, aerospace and defense applications

Salt Environments, open seas, and salt spray environments

Care should be taken, surface treatment MUST be used, limited life should be expected

Stable in this environment

Acid environments

Surface treatment is necessary, limited life can be expected

Stable in this environment, however, qualification tests recommended

Alkaline environments

NeSurface treatment is necessary, limited life can be expected

Stable in this environment, however, qualification tests recommended

Thin walled, thin cross-section applications (a dimension below 0.040")

Mechanically stable, parts have been made as thin as 0.008” thick

Not very good in very thin cross-sections. Under 0.020” is not recommended

Single piece large parts

Better than SmCo, larger blocks can be sintered

Larger blocks (over 3” in any dimension) is challenging

Nickel Plating per military specifications

Not available – Plating is done to proprietary specifications, only Electrolytic Nickel is available

Electroless and electrolytic nickel plating is available. Mil-C-26074 can be complied to

Plating per military specifications

Not available. All platings are done per proprietary specifications.

Not typically used. Call factory for more information

PR1010 coating

Available

Available

Radial ring configuration (so as to obtain a true radially oriented field)

Available for custom parts.

Not available

Sensitivity of Flux Density, Br, and Coercivity, Hc, to temperature changes

The Temperature Coefficient of Br (%/°C) ranges from NEGATIVE (0.11 to 0.13). Higher coercivity materials (>20 kOe) are closer to negative (0.11)

The Temperature Coefficient of Hc (%/°C) ranges from NEGATIVE (0.51 to 0.77). The higher the intrinsic coercivity, the lower the Temperature Coefficient of Hc

The Temperature Coefficient of Br (%/°C) ranges from NEGATIVE (0.03 to 0.04). Series Sm2Co17 are less sensitive to temperature changes (around negative 0.03) than SmCo5 (around negative 0.04)

The Temperature Coefficient of Hc (%/°C) ranges from NEGATIVE (0.15 to 0.24). Series Sm2Co17 are less sensitive to temperature changes (around negative 0.15) than SmCo5 (around negative 0.24)

Rate this article:
 

Log on

© 2001-2009 Magnetic Component Engineering, Inc.